I'm a couple months late with this commentary, but that's one of the nice things about blogging as a hobby rather than a livelihood: There are no deadlines or quotas, and I write when I feel like writing. If something's worth commenting on, it's worth doing at any time!
As I mentioned recently, I am getting burned out on politics. So following is the first of what I hope are many non-politics-related commentaries...
To no one’s surprise, Sears filed for bankruptcy back in October. The 125-year-old company will close hundreds of stores, attempt to sell others, and ask for relief from creditors while it attempts to shape itself up in short order. It's incredible to contemplate, but as recently as the late 1980s, Sears was the nation's largest retailer. First KMart (also on the critical list), then Target, WalMart and others gradually made major inroads. Today, those "conquerors" are suffering from massive online sales -- particularly involving Amazon.com.
Like many other department stores that failed to adapt to consumer preferences and modern technological trends such as e-commerce, Sears is an anachronism. The "five-and-dimes" or dime stores of the 1970s and earlier such as Kresge, Woolworth's and Jupiter closed shop decades ago. Dollar Tree, Family Dollar and Dollar General are today's version of five-and-dimes, albeit with much more limited selections and sans the cool lunch counters that aging Baby Boomers such as yours truly fondly recall.
Full-fledged department stores and catalog outlets have been dropping like flies in recent decades: Montgomery Ward, Younkers, Hudson's, May, Mervyn's and the southern chain Rich's are just a few of the hundreds of casualties. Established giants such as Nieman Marcus, J.C. Penney and Macy's are reeling, and have had to do their own cost-cutting / store closings. It will be a heartbreak if Penney closes; that has long been one of my favorite stores because of its reasonable quality clothing and shoes, decent prices and frequent sales.
In my Baby Boomer mind, Sears is as American as baseball and apple pie. Back in the day, the full name was Sears, Roebuck & Co. When I was 5 or 6, I thought it was "Sears Robot." My two fondest memories of the Sears store in my hometown of Midland, Mich. Are the Christmas catalogs and how I loved to look at the HO scale racing and train sets, along with other toys; and the 5-speed bicycle I bought at Sears with my paper route money when I was 11 years old.
Even at the ages of 11, I was curious about who manufactured Sears bicycles. I asked a Sears employee, and learned it was Dayton, Ohio-based Huffy, which had a reputation for affordable and halfway decent bikes, but not for the reliability and quality of Schwinn, which was the standard of the day. The gearshift/derailleur system was built by Shimano Skylark. The Japanese company still exists, manufacturing bicycle parts, fishing gear and rowing equipment.
Three years later, I had saved more paper route money, and moved up in the world, purchasing a Miyata 10-speed on sale for the then princely sum of $100. (Loved that bike, but alas, it was stolen in broad daylight from outside my house in the summer of 1978.) But back to Sear's...
My memories of Sears cannot really be chronicled in a smooth narrative; nor are they related. They're more like a mosaic of experiences and observations. Here's some unfiltered stream-of-consciousness:
-- Although Sears had some toys, it was, and still is, known more for hardware, automotive parts and appliances. If I was lucky as a 10-year-old, there would be some Tyco and Aurora HO scale racing sets and model railroad packages to look at in person. But the catalog had a much bigger selection. Several times, I ordered TycoPro or Aurora AFX cars through the catalog, and just couldn't wait to pick them up. My Catholic grade school was right across the street from the Sears store, and one of my classmates and I both were into the racing & train sets. I recall one day being out on the playground and seeing a semi-truck backed up to the Sears loading dock. "I think that truck is delivering catalog orders, and my Chaparral might be arriving today," I said. "Could be," he replied."Let's go find out after school."
-- My house was only about 4 1/2-5 blocks from the store. This seems insane now, in an era of pervert predators and child abductions, but I recall my dad sending me down to Sears to buy something (I think it was a plumbing part for a faucet he was repairing.) Seems I was only 7 or 8 years old. I was painfully shy and afraid to ask a salesperson for help. I walked around looking at the shelves and fiddling around with faucets on display. Soon my dad and brother arrived in the store, and he asked me if I had found what he was looking for. He was disgusted that I hadn't, and mildly chastised me. Looking back, I figure he was trying to instill confidence in me. I also remember him forcing me to call a store and ask if they sold a certain item. (Don't recall whether it was Sears.) I was timid, but managed to get through it. Later on in life, I realized that dealing with anxiety and shyness was a cauldron that helped me develop some communications skills and confidence that would pay off later on. But these painful experiences were like going through a boot camp or football training camp. Horrible while experiencing it; but later on, you're damned glad you paid your dues and can reap the benefits.
-- The Sears in my hometown, like many of them, had an auto repair shop. I recall going there with my dad on Saturday's to get something done to the car. Usually, the mechanics were blasting the radio. One day, Simon & Garfunkel's "Cecilia" filled the grimy garage with its beautiful harmonies. I couldn't get that song out of my head for the rest of the night. About 10-12 years later, when I owned a car, I took it to Sears a few times for minor repairs. It was a good place to buy a battery or tire, or get shock absorbers or brake shoes installed. I also occasionally frequented the Kmart garage across town, but that closed down many years ago. Although a few Kmarts are still hanging on, few of them still have automotive centers.
-- Way back, when I was in grade school, my older sister received a Sears Silvertone acuoustic guitar as a Christmas present. That old thing sat around the house for many years, and I recall playing it well into my teens. I never took lessons, and was trying to play a right-handed guitar left-handed (a la Jimi Hendrix).
-- When I graduated from high school, my dad gave me a Craftsman toolbox and some tools for a graduation gift. To this day, I still use some of those sockets & ratchets. There may even be a screwdriver or two still in my possession. I believe a hacksaw was included, which helped for cutting tubes, pipes or small branches out in the yard. For bike repairs, simple car repairs and things around the house, that toolbox has really come in handy for decades.
-- Lansing has a Sears in a rambling, somewhat homely shopping center called Frandor, opened in 1954 and updated a couple times, but still kind of an anachronism in today's era of sleek strip shopping centers and luxury malls. A side note: There aren't any traffic islands or one-way streets to order the traffic flow in Frandor's massive parking lot surrounded by major streets on the border of Lansing and East Lansing. That parking lot, with kamikazee drivers going too fast, diagonally and in every direction, is somewhat crazy to drive through. In the winter, when plows put giant snow hills at random locations, this obstructs visibility and reduces available parking spaces. Frandor has a few good businesses, including Panera Bread, World Market, Home Goods, a hardware store and one of the larger Sears stores I've ever seen. When it comes to tools, lawn and garden equipment and appliances, this Sears has a tremendous selection. We bought our refrigerator and range there, and either our washer or drier -- don't recall which. There's also an automotive repair center. Don't think I've actually had my car serviced there, but have purchased a few things over the years including batteries and filters. It will be a blow if this Sears shuts down.
-- Back to Midland... The Sears on Main Street closed sometime in the late 1980s, if memory serves. The building was converted into a county social services administrative building. Five years ago I reminisced about the Midland S.S. Kresge and Woolworth's stores. That Kresge's closed in 1982; Woolworth's about 7-8 years later, and the J.C. Penney in downtown Midland moved to the Midland Mall probably 25 years ago. Just last year, the store closed. Today, downtown Midland has a senior citizens home, some high-end condominiums, a nice hotel with excellent restaurants (built largely to accommodate visitors in town to do business with Dow-Dupont). There are a few other restaurants and specialty businesses (shoe repair, for example), but little in the way of retail. Maybe just a few small mom-n-pop shops.
-- In 2005, Sears and Kmart merged under Sears Holding Company. Talk about the blind leading the blind! Both of these stores were sickly even before Amazon.com began running roughshod over the entire retail world. Going back to the late 1990s, I recall reading stories about how new management was going to update Kmart's antiquated inventory system and technology; pour money into remodeling its dowdy stores, blah-blah... But to this day, you walk into a Kmart and it's like being in a time machine. Suddenly, it's 1965, and you're wondering if Andy & Barney Fife will show up. Shelves often are empty, displays are tattered and poorly designed, signage looks cheap. I've long called Kmart the Keith Richards of retail. HOW is it still alive??? Sears stores aren't as pathetic when it comes to shelves, displays and decor, but their whole business model is sluggishly plodding along, and unless something drastic happens, Sears and Kmart will vanish soon.
All across the nation, downtown areas and shopping malls are hurting. Millions of consumers prefer to buy items online, and why not? It's quick and convenient. No spending time and gas money, going out into the cold, trying to find a parking space, fighting traffic... I've done it myself, mainly for books, CDs, DVDs and a few other small items. But I'm an old-school guy when it comes to clothing, winter wear and shoes. I need to see the articles in person, feel the fabric, try them on and look in the mirror. Too often, what's ordered online might not be quite what you're looking for. At least that's been my experience. I also actually enjoy the human contact. The little greetings and interactions with other shoppers and sales clerks are not a part of e-commerce transactions.
There's no turning back the hands of time, so I know I'm going against the grain. But something is being lost with the devastation of retail. Somehow, I don't think today's millennials, when they're in their 50s and 60s, will fondly recall their smartphones, Amazon apps or front porch package deliveries from 40 years ago. But then, what do I know?
Recent Comments