Posse Incitatus

Spartan footballers rape Duke lacrosse team

Amidst the brouhaha about the Spartan Football Follies, it seems worthwhile to put things in perspective.

Already the Drew Sharps of the world are working themselves up into righteous indignation.  Before the executions begin, however, let us make sure we know what the crimes are.

I say this not as an apologist, but as a rationalist.  That is to say, I’m all for executions pour encourages les autres, but only if they are deserved.  These are my reasons for hesitation:

1.  We are only getting one side of the story.  As Sharp himself puts it:

The attorney representing one of the suspected victims said eyewitnesses told campus police that 15-20 men, most thought to be football players and a few wearing ski masks, crashed the affair and triggered violence.

MSU has said nothing.  The prosecutor has said nothing.  We effectively have no facts to go on, just the account of someone who has a clear interest in prepping the jury pool for a possible civil lawsuit.  This leads me to…

2.  Why does a victim even have an attorney?  If I get robbed, mugged, or otherwise assaulted, I don’t go and lawyer up, I go to the cops.  I know what many of you are thinking: what if I have to use force in self-defense?  Of course I would hire an attorney.  Which is exactly my point.  This person’s actions are indicative of someone who was not purely a bystander or victim.  Note the language of the attorney:  the players "crashed the affair and triggered violence."   Who threw the first punch?  We don't know.

3.  The press cannot be trusted.  We know this.  They always stick to the narrative, whether it is that gun control works, global warming is scientifically proven, racist hillbillies lynch census workers or that MSU football players like to start fights for random reasons.  This attorney has helped to shape the narrative, and the press is happy to play along because it is exactly what they want to report.

Let me give you three words to put this in perspective:  Duke Lacrosse Team.  Remember them?  The accusations were far worse, the furor far greater, and all of it – every detail – was wrong.  It was so wrong that the prosecutor was disbarred.  With that in mind, I’m not in any hurry to make my judgement.

Already, we are seeing cracks in the storyline that has been peddled. The Freep has started talking to parents, and while the squad doesn’t look good, it is a far cry from the “ski-mask-wearing-thugs-on-a-rampage” story we’ve been hearing.

Once all the facts emerge, we can then evaluate whether Dantonio has done the right thing, but not before.

Dantonio does the right thing

In my younger days, I was often harshly critical of college coaches who tolerated any kind of misbehavior from their student athletes. Being on the team was a privilege, not a right.

Thus, any infraction that brought disrepute on the team and university should be strongly and harshly punished.

Ah, for the certitudes of youth! What a luxury it was to not have many any mistakes!

The older I’ve gotten, the more I’ve come to realize that screwing up is as inevitable as breathing – the question is how you respond to your mistakes. A zero-defect mentality quickly becomes a zero-accomplishment reality.

Thus, when I heard about Glenn Winston’s involvement in the fracas with the hockey team, I (like many fans) wondered whether he should be allowed back on the team. Coach Mark Dantonio announced that he had learned his lesson and changed his ways. And for a while, it seemed this was so.

Similarly, Roderick Jenrette had still-undisclosed “personal issues” to work out last season. Again, the coach gave him space and presumably guidance to take care of things.

And then there comes this story of a dorm brawl. The details aren’t clear, but both Winston and Jeanrette are off the team. Permanently.

This is as it should be. The wheels of justice will continue to grind forward, but Dantonio’s actions are exactly right: no benefit of the doubt, no third chance. All he needed to know was that they were somehow, tangentially involved. They knew the stakes and now their athletic careers here are over.

Incidents like this are always wonderful opportunities for opposing fans to taunt each other, but I think MSU is on firm ground here. You screw up? We can help. You do it again, you’re on your own.

Lest people forget, collegiate sports aren’t about creating pro athletes. Most college athletes won’t go pro. What college sports really do is give solid life experiences to those that participate. In the right circumstances, the afterglow can last a lifetime.

Successful coaches are more than trophy-winners, they are mentors. One of the reason Tom Izzo is so worshipped here is that he does more than win games – he helps his players. Always, in every way. He wants them to succeed on and off the court.

Dantonio is cut of the same cloth. He knew Winston and Jenrette had issues. He cut them slack. He went out of his way to help. And they effectively threw it back in his face.

That doesn’t mean he should have made the offer; it merely means they should have taken that chance more seriously.

And now, basketball season

I remember when the Big Ten was a football conference.  No more.  They are rapidly losing ground to the MAC in terms of gridiron prowess, but at least the hardwood belongs to the Conference That Can't Count.

What can one say about the regular football season that has finally, mercifully drawn to a close?

For the Spartans, it was almost as bitter as the John L. Smith days, a series of disasters punctuated by moments of glory. We can comfort ourselves by saying that MSU was three plays away from being 9-3, but the Spartans were also two more plays from being 4-8.  Those moments add up, and part of moving to the next level is being the kind of team that captures those moments.

Mark Dantonio has his work cut out for him, and part of that work is educating his staff.  They need more strategy.  Discipline will only go so far; the Spartans also need some skilled generalship.  Too many plays were botched in the booth, from the senseless quarterback rotation to the pig-headed insistence on establishing the run when it simply wasn't going to happen.

Still, next year the Spartan faithful have much to look forward to.  The senior class is taking few standouts and both running back and QB positions will show marked improvement.  Keith Nichol by now should be the backup, but his skills should not be overlooked.  During the off season, Dantonio should look at using him for special plays or as a slot receiver.  He's fast and has a good arm - putting both Cousins and Nichol on the field at the same time would give opposing defensive coordinators fits.

Hopefully they will use the bowl as a chance to open up the playbook.

Meanwhile, the snow in Ann Arbor is about six feet deep.  I suppose a victory lap is in order regarding my March 25 5-7 prediction, and we'll have to wait a few weeks to see if coach RichRod will last into the new year.  As I said before, the question is how the NCAA investigation goes.  If sanctions are likely, RichRod is toast.  Stick a fork in 'im, he's done.

As a good Spartan fan, I should at this point remind what few readers I have that like the Skunk Bears that I hope he stays on indefinately.  This is a long and storied rivalry and it will take years of MSU victories to tip it in our favor.  So keep him, please.

Final weekend

I missed the MSU game due to unexpected travel plans, and it's probably just as well: my heart probably couldn't take another close-run game.  Still, better to win ugly than lose ugly.

Penn State will close out the season and MSU has a fair chance of pulling off the upset.  Unlike last year, we have yet to be blown off the football field.  Unfortunately, we're also beating ourselves in frustratingly close games.  Without these friendly fire incidents, we'd be 9-2 rather than 6-5.  Oh well, the Spartans still have a decent chance at a decent bowl game - though at this point we have to take what we can get.

Down the road in Ann Arbor, the wheels are really coming off the wagon.  Last spring, I ventured a bold prediction that will likely be half-correct: the Skunk Bears are poised to go 5-7 though RichRod will likely survive to pound the last ounce of prestige from the program - and set some new (losing) records.

This was not a popular position to take in September, but oh how the mighty have fallen.  It's like John L. Smith is running the show down there (4-0 start and 1-7 finish).  The fact that the OSU game starts at noon speaks volumes - it's almost an afterthought.  A far cry from the prime-time showdowns of years gone by.

I still think RichRod would be given the axe but for Athletic Director Bill "Do you know who I am?!!" Martin essentially serving as a human shield until his retirement next September.  Obviously Martin is loathe to give the guy he hired the sack and then look for a replacement at this stage.  So RichRod will probably be whacked a year from now, though if he is able to crawl into a bowl game before then, he may survive to delight Spartan fans for years go come.

It all comes down to this

This Saturday's game against Purdue is the second-most important game of the season.  The most important was the game against Michigan - not only because it was a rivalry game, but also because that was a pivot point that saved the season.

Of course, the season can yet be lost, but a victory over Purdue makes that much less likely.  Given the state of the Big Ten, beating Purdue pretty much locks MSU into a (admittedly crappy) bowl game.  It knocks Purdue out of contention, and moves MSU up within the conference.

In this respect it is therefore a much bigger deal than beating Penn State.  Obviously, I'd like to win both games.  But this week is more consequential.  (Of course, if MSU had beaten Notre Dame, Iowa and CMU, we'd be 8-2 and already have picked out our floral shirts for the trip to someplace warm, but I digress).

Meanwhile, Michigan's woes continue.  Their athletic director apparently likes to shove university security around when asked for identification, but in the best interests of the school, there's no need to actually file charges.

With games against Wisconsin and Ohio State looming, the highly-paid coach of the 5-5 Skunk Bears has got to feeling the heat.

It is worth noting that his lucrative salary figures don't include the $2.5 million the University of Michigan is paying to cover his buyout from West Virginia.  That's a lot of money to shell out for a guy whose accomplishments to date have mostly centered on setting records for losses - both in quantity and quality.

The next two weeks will be crucial for both programs. 

We were Spartans once, and young...

I've not discussed the game at Minnesota because frankly, I find the whole matter too depressing for words.

I just don't get this team.  They have the talent, but can't seem to close the deal.  Just when it looks like they are about to reach the next level, they drop to a new low.  How can one explain the whipsawing from the stingy goal-line stands against Iowa to giving up a career day to one of the Big Ten's worst quarterbacks?

In the interest of maintaining my sanity, I have to back off this team.  If they win, great.  But emotionally, I just can't be that invested in them any more.

Hiring victories

Well, Saturday offered gifts for both the Spartans and the Skunk Bears.

MSU was fortunate that it wasn't down by 28 at the half.  It was a pathetic offensive performance, worthy of a blowout loss.  Only Northwestern's ineptitude (and our resurgent defense) kept us alive.

The second half was a different story.  We won't have that luxury next week.  Though I remain firmly convinced that Iowa is a fraud, the Hawkeyes are also lucky, and therefore undefeated.

Given the wacky on/off nature of my beloved Spartans, I hesitate to guess which way things will go.  I'm inclined to say that MSU will rise to the occasion, relishing the chance to take down an undefeated, highly ranked opponent and gain back some respect.

On the other hand, the last time we had opportunities like this - last year - we got blown off the field.  Could go either way.

Meanwhile, I hear there was quite the game in Ann Arbor over the weekend.  Money can't buy love, but it apparently can buy a Division I-AA team to pad your bowl resume.   I know, that's the way things are going these days, and MSU decided to join the trend with Montana State Junior College earlier this year.  On the other hand, Montana State didn't forfeit a conference game just to make the trip.  When we Spartans buy wins, we pay full price.  The Skunk Bears demand a discount.

At least Michigan was classy enough not to run up the score.

Where all the football players are above average

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: If you are a fan of the University of Michigan, you should loathe Coach Rich Rodriquez with every fiber of your being.

As the Freep points out, he has once again started telling whoppers – this time about the brilliant and unprecedented grades his teams are getting.

This wasn’t a one-time gaffe. He didn’t just get carried away with his own rhetoric. He made repeated specific claims which – according to his own university officials – cannot be backed up in any way shape or form.

Why did he do this? The most obvious reason would be to deflect attention from his team’s poor performance and possible NCAA rules violations. “Yeah, we’re getting crushed, and maybe we cheat, but man, are we SMART!”

It’s a talking point – and apparently a wholly bogus one.

You can’t throw out specifics like “best ever” and “best in 25 years” based on a guess. Sportswriters (and sports fans) are all about hard numbers. Either the back rushed for 100 yards or he didn’t. I recall a game where Javon Ringer rushed 99 yards. He was one yard away, but didn’t quite get there. No 100-yard game.

I am a Spartan fan. Thus, the Skunk Bears are my arch-rivals. Yet I can respect the U-M basketball coach because he seems like an honest, capable man – well-respected by his peers and the basketball community. When he left West Virginia, he did so on the up-and-up. No skullduggery, lawsuits, etc.

RichRod is a totally different sort, and the manner in which he came to Michigan should have tipped people off that he was not a particularly honest character.

What amuses me is the reaction of commenters – both on the Free Press site and on this thread. For some bizarre reason, the U-M faithful are closing ranks around a man who has to this point done nothing but embarrass them. It is something I simply do not understand.

The only thing he has accomplished is that he (allegedly) recruits well. So what? Bo recruited well. Mo recruited well. Lloyd recruited well. None of them have performed as poorly.

The irony is that the Freep is otherwise very pro-Skunk Bears.  This story almost certainly didn't start as a "gotcha" but rather an attempt to highlight the coach's claims.  One can almost visualize the graphic showing a winged helmet and ever-higher GPAs.  Alas, RichRod was talking out of his hat.

Spartans bring Zookerdammerung - plus Fraudeyes beat Fraudverines

For the first time in a month, I was able to settle in and watch a solid afternoon of college football.

The Spartans handily demolished the Ron Zook-led Illini, who seem to be returning to their hapless form.  Ron Zook was of course the Florida coach who brought in great recruits but got canned because he couldn't win.

So Illinois hired him, and he brought in great recruits, had one awesome season, and is now demonstrating that he can't win.

MSU's victory comes with a price - Glenn Winston is out for the season, and Larry Caper also left early - both injuries apparently caused by the ultra-high-friction carpet they use in Champaign.

Keith Nichol also got dinged, though no one is saying how much.

Having enjoyed a quantity of good German beer during this performance, I proceeded to nap during most of the OSU-Wisconsin game - the first half was quite the snoozer - so don't ask me what I think.

The main event, of course, was the long-awaited showdown between the Maize and Blue and the Maize-cutting Hawkeyes.

This was a comedy of errors.  Two utterly overrated teams (Iowa is the 12th-best team in the nation?  Really?) staggered back and forth across the field, vying with one another to see who can make the most bone-headed calls.  Iowa set a high bar with their first passing attempt, but Michigan rose to the challenge, treating us to a display reminiscent of last year's "how many ways can we cough up the ball?" odyssey.

My heart goes out to Tate Forcier (not his real name, apparently) for the abuse he got from RichRod.  Here you have a kid, aggressively recruited, highly touted and constantly dinged-up who has put (possibly illegal) amounts of time in practice to help the team.  And what thanks does he get?  The bench.

Anyone remember last year's sensation at running back?  The one who quit?  And what about Ryan Mallett?  I wonder how he would do with a half-decent team.

As for Iowa, the only reason they stand a chance against MSU is that, well, it's MSU we are talking about.  The suicidal impulse runs deep in the green and white, despite Mark Dantonio's efforts to exorcise it (perhaps we should contact the Diocese?).

Had the Spartans not pissed away three games in September, we might be somewhere by now, but, as it stands, the season is not yet lost.  Contrary my esteemed co-blogger T.Mo., talk of a Big Ten title at this point is utterly deluded.  I'm still wondering if we can get to 7-5.

Credit where it is due:  I suspect that RichRod will get the Skunk Bears into a bowl game, thanks to a schedule that keeps them at home most of the time.  Question for the week: will Delaware State be Montana State or Appalachian State?   Hmmm, they had a good year in 2007, but are otherwise unremarkable.

I'd put money on the upset just 'cause, but I'm like that.

Winning should feel better than this

The Spartans have now beaten the Skunk Bears in consecutive games for the first time since 1967 - the glory years of Spartan dominance.

Given this achievement, nay milestone, I should be in full gloat mode.  Had we beaten CMU or Notre Dame, I would be (Wisconsin didn't bother me so much - Madison is a tough place to play).

But we aren't out of the woods yet.  This team is designed to induce a combination of hypertension and alcoholism in already overstressed fans.  If we can handle the next couple of games, I may relax.

Over at the Detroit Free Press, the usual sports columnists are doing their usual best to piss off the Spartan faithful, and their pointy-eared acolytes in the comments section are joining in.  The funniest comments are those from Skunk Bear lovers which imply that the Spartans made a mistake in hiring Mark Dantonio.  Er, no.  This season is clearly a disappointment, but (as the Spartan faithful have pointed out) even the miiighty Tom Izzo has had an off season or two since taking the helm.  Is anyone suggesting that the basketball team would be better off without Izzo? 

No, if anyone should be having buyer's remorse, it is the administration in Ann Arbor.  Consider the historic records college football's most storied program has now achieved under RichRod:

• Most losses in a single season
• End of historic bowl streak
• First loss to MAC team, and of course
• First back-to-back losses to MSU since 1967.

But at least they beat Indiana.

Oh, and how is that NCAA investigation going?  Remembering that they got to pay $1.5 million extra for this guy to get out of his contract with West Virginia, having him get sanctioned would be the icing on the cake.

If I read the schedule rightly, their next stop is Iowa, where I suspect they will be demolished.  Tate Forcier will be lucky if he doesn't leave the field in a body cast. 

And of course there are the Buckeyes waiting below the horizon, like a freight train picking up speed.  When was the last time U-M lost to both of its rivals for two years in a row?  That's got to be some kind of record, too.